One of the nice things about heating oil is that you can order it and have it delivered completely based on your schedule! This gives you the freedom to order when you need it. Systems with multiple tanks might only need to get a fill-up every couple of months. Sometimes, even only two or three times a year! Other systems with only one tank might need to get a fill-up several times a year to make sure that they’ve always got oil in the tank.
But with all these examples of getting fill-ups, what’s the best time to get one? Below, I’ll be going over everything that helps determine what the best time to order oil for your home is! Feel free to bookmark this article to revisit later or write down anything that catches your eye!

What Causes Oil Prices to Change
Figuring out the best time to order oil can be difficult. Especially with how erratic oil prices can be! Especially during heating oil season! But there are two primary reasons why heating oil prices fluctuate so much. They are the following:
- Crude Oil Supply and Demand
- Dealers Competing for Prices and Customers
- How You Order Oil – Either Call-by or Automatic Delivery
Crude Oil Supply and Demand
Prices of crude oil have a direct effect on heating oil prices. Heating oil derives from crude oil, which tends to mean that global changes affect its pricing. We’ve seen this happen twice, once with COVID-19 in 2020 and this year with the US’s war with Iran. These events caused prices to change drastically. Crude oil is not only used in heating oil, but also in jet fuel, diesel, gasoline, and several lubricants for machinery. So heating oil’s price will be directly affected by Crude Oil’s price.
Using COVID-19 as an example, prices for heating oil were at an all-time low! This was due to the lockdown and travel bans. This caused a surplus of crude oil. Everybody was home because of the pandemic, so prices tanked. The number of people traveling and commuting to work dropped significantly. The war that happened with Iran this year is a different story. Iran has blocked off the Strait of Hormuz, resulting in 20% of the world’s oil being inaccessible. This resulted in high prices for heating oil, gasoline, and jet fuel. The surge in prices was actually the final nail in the coffin for Spirit Airlines, which ceased operations in May of this year.

Heating Oil’s Local Supply and Demand
This plays a major role when it comes to heating oil prices. In Long Island, there are thousands of homes that use heating oil as their primary source of heat. Because of this, there are a lot of heating oil dealers there. This makes the market in Long Island very competitive. Dealers have to be both diligent and provide the fastest possible delivery to keep up with the hyper-competitive Long Island market! However, prices do tend to be cheaper in Long Island.
Towns with a lower population will only have a small number of dealers. This means that in these small-town markets, only one or two heating oil dealers will be in the area. This tends to give them full rein over their prices. They can charge whatever they want for heating oil. This can be mildly frustrating when prices get expensive. Especially with the upsurge in heating oil prices.
Now, here’s the big question. What’s the best time to order heating oil? Usually, the summer is the best time to buy oil. This is because demand is lower. However, be careful, because of the lower demand, dealers tend to be less obligated to lower prices because they won’t be making as many deliveries as they would during the winter. Sometimes, the price can be a little higher during this time. Overall, supply and demand for crude oil are what’ll ultimately drive the prices to be lower or higher. But if you do see a good price, then definitely place an order!
Automatic vs Call-by Delivery
Price fluctuation is normal for the current state of the heating oil market. But there are two very important things that you’re going to want to understand! The price you’ll end up paying is heavily influenced by automatic delivery or a call. Both of these delivery methods will heavily influence the price you pay per gallon. Automatic delivery, for example, will tend to offer a more “luxury” price.
When it comes to automatic delivery, heating oil prices might be anywhere between .50 to a dollar more per gallon! Just imagine it! You could be spending at least $1000 more every winter on heating oil by using automatic delivery! Meanwhile, your friend is actually spending $1000 less than you on oil because they’re using call-by delivery.

Many dealers will do a call-by delivery for you! As long as the fill-up isn’t an emergency, you won’t have any additional fees! You can use our FuelSnap website to get the best prices available in your area! However, if you don’t want to run out of oil, then get a Smart Oil Gauge! The sensor will be able to upload to our app, and it’ll keep track of heating oil usage and level data for you!
What’s the Verdict?
Due to all of the contributing factors for what determines the price of heating oil, there’s actually no best time to order. So it might not matter when exactly you order. However, prices during the summer might be a little cheaper. If they are, and you want to fill up, then go for it! The only real exception to this would be getting oil during the winter. It’s a bit more difficult to get it promptly during this time!
Even if there are major snowstorms or a cold snap, you should still be able to check prices! Checking prices on FuelSnap or your dealer’s website is still a great way for you to get an idea of how much heating oil prices are, and it will give you an idea of when to order!
But please keep in mind that you shouldn’t be letting your tank get low! Doing this will put your system at risk of getting damaged from running out. If you’ve got an older tank, then this puts your system at risk of sucking up sludge in the feedlines! This could lead to more serious problems, such as frozen pipes. This could lead to much more expensive and time-consuming problems. So make sure to be on top of your oil level and don’t let it run out!
Happy Heating!
Hunter



